What if? movies like Indecent Proposal
Explore the compelling world where desire clashes with morality. These films delve deep into the intricacies of relationships, offering a fascinating look at the choices people make when faced with tempting offers or forbidden attractions.



The allure of forbidden love and the ripple effects of a single, life-altering decision have captivated audiences for decades. From the iconic 1993 film Indecent Proposal, where a million-dollar offer tests the boundaries of a marriage, to the psychologically intense Eyes Wide Shut, these movies explore the complex tapestry of human desire and fidelity.
What makes these stories so compelling is their ability to dissect the very fabric of relationships, exposing the raw emotions and difficult choices that arise when temptation comes knocking. Think about Fatal Attraction, a film that not only defined a genre but also sparked a national conversation about infidelity and its terrifying consequences. Or consider the groundbreaking Basic Instinct, which pushed the envelope with its provocative themes and iconic performances, leaving audiences on the edge of their seats.
These films often feature brilliant performances from actors who bravely portray characters grappling with their deepest desires and the societal pressures that come with them. They challenge us to consider: What would you do? How far would you go? This genre isn't just about illicit affairs; it's about the psychological toll, the moral dilemmas, and the irreversible shifts that occur when boundaries are crossed. Prepare to be drawn into a world where every decision has a price, and the consequences linger long after the credits roll.
14. The Great Gatsby (2013)
The Great Gatsby, in its 2013 iteration, is a dazzling and visually extravagant adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic novel. Directed by Baz Luhrmann, the film plunges viewers into the opulent and decadent world of the Roaring Twenties with his signature maximalist style. Leonardo DiCaprio delivers a compelling performance as the enigmatic Jay Gatsby, capturing his desperate romanticism and tragic ambition. Carey Mulligan is ethereal as Daisy Buchanan, the object of his obsession, and Tobey Maguire serves as the wide-eyed narrator, Nick Carraway.\n\nLuhrmann's approach to the material is undeniably bold, utilizing vibrant colors, intricate set designs, and a modern soundtrack (featuring artists like Jay-Z and Lana Del Rey) to bridge the gap between classic literature and contemporary cinematic spectacle. The film is a feast for the senses, recreating the Jazz Age with a lavish, almost dreamlike quality.\n\nOne fascinating aspect is how Luhrmann uses 3D technology not just as a gimmick, but to immerse the audience deeper into Gatsby's fantastical, yet ultimately hollow, world. While it sparked debate among purists, this adaptation is a passionate and stylized interpretation of a timeless story about love, illusion, and the American Dream.

13. The Descendants (2011)
The Descendants is a poignant and beautifully observed dramedy that showcases George Clooney in one of his most understated and powerful performances as Matt King, a Hawaiian land baron forced to confront his family's past and future. After a tragic accident leaves his wife comatose, Matt attempts to reconnect with his two daughters and grapple with a major decision about his family's ancestral land. The film offers a heartfelt look at grief, forgiveness, and the complexities of family relationships.\n\nDirected by Alexander Payne, known for his character-driven narratives, the film expertly balances humor with genuine emotion. The stunning Hawaiian backdrop provides a stark contrast to Matt's internal turmoil, adding a unique visual texture to the story. The supporting cast, including Shailene Woodley as his rebellious daughter, delivers strong performances that anchor the emotional core of the film.\n\nDid you know that the film's depiction of Hawaiian culture and land ownership was meticulously researched to ensure authenticity? 'The Descendants' is a deeply human story that reminds us that life, even in paradise, is full of unexpected challenges and profound connections.

12. The Graduate (1967)
The Graduate is a seminal film that perfectly captures the ennui and rebellion of a generation. Dustin Hoffman became an overnight star as Benjamin Braddock, a recent college graduate adrift in a world he doesn't understand, who finds himself entangled in an affair with the older, sophisticated Mrs. Robinson, played unforgettably by Anne Bancroft. Their dynamic is iconic, exploring themes of disillusionment, conformity, and the search for authentic connection in a cynical world.\n\nDirector Mike Nichols masterfully blends humor, drama, and social commentary, creating a film that feels both timeless and deeply rooted in its era. The innovative cinematography and editing, particularly the famous montage sequences, were groundbreaking and influential. And, of course, the film's soundtrack by Simon & Garfunkel is legendary, perfectly underscoring Benjamin's emotional journey.\n\nOne of the most enduring elements is the character of Mrs. Robinson herself, who, despite her predatory nature, became a complex and captivating figure, a symbol of forbidden allure. The film's ambiguous ending sparked countless discussions and remains a powerful statement on youthful rebellion. 'The Graduate' is more than just a movie; it's a cultural phenomenon that continues to resonate with new generations.

11. Last Tango in Paris (1972)
Last Tango in Paris is a raw, controversial, and deeply introspective film that explores the dark corners of human desire and despair. Marlon Brando delivers one of his most powerful and unsettling performances as Paul, an American widower who enters into an anonymous, purely sexual relationship with a young Parisian woman. Maria Schneider, as Jeanne, is equally compelling, capturing the confusion and vulnerability of a woman navigating a profoundly unconventional connection.\n\nDirected by Bernardo Bertolucci, the film is renowned for its intense emotional realism and its unflinching depiction of a relationship stripped of societal conventions. It delves into themes of grief, alienation, and the desperate search for connection, even if it's found in the most transgressive ways. The film's improvisational feel adds to its visceral impact, making it feel incredibly immediate and personal.\n\nDid you know that the film was highly controversial upon its release, facing censorship and legal battles in various countries due to its explicit content and themes? Despite, or perhaps because of, the controversy, it remains a significant work in cinematic history, a bold and challenging exploration of human sexuality and emotion.

10. Chloe (2010)
Chloe is a sophisticated and psychologically complex thriller that delves into the fragile nature of trust and desire. Julianne Moore delivers a nuanced performance as Catherine Stewart, a successful doctor who, suspecting her husband of infidelity, hires a high-end escort to test his loyalty. Amanda Seyfried is captivating as Chloe, the enigmatic escort who blurs the lines between professional duty and personal entanglement. Liam Neeson provides a subtle, understated performance as the potentially unfaithful husband.\n\nDirected by Atom Egoyan, the film is a masterclass in building tension through ambiguity and unspoken desires. It's less about explicit acts and more about the emotional and psychological fallout of suspicion and manipulation. The film's sleek, almost clinical aesthetic perfectly complements its exploration of hidden vulnerabilities and the dangerous games people play with each other's affections. \n\nA curious fact: 'Chloe' is a remake of the 2004 French film 'Nathalie...', and Egoyan's version brings a distinct North American sensibility to the tale, exploring themes of surveillance and modern relationships with a keen eye. It's a chilling, thought-provoking film that will leave you questioning the nature of truth and intimacy.

9. Wild Things (1998)
Wild Things is a twisty, salacious neo-noir that keeps you guessing from start to finish. Kevin Bacon, Matt Dillon, Neve Campbell, and Denise Richards are all perfectly cast in this intricate tale of sex, lies, and murder in the steamy Florida Everglades. The film is famous for its multiple shocking reveals and its willingness to push boundaries, making it a thrilling ride for anyone who loves a good mystery with a generous dose of scandal.\n\nDirector John McNaughton crafts a stylish and deliberately misleading narrative, constantly subverting expectations and revealing new layers of deception. The film's sun-drenched, humid setting adds another layer of sweaty tension to the already complex plot. It's a film that demands your full attention, as every character seems to have a hidden agenda.\n\nDid you know that the film's notorious pool scene, which became a topic of much discussion, was carefully choreographed to maximize its impact and surprise? 'Wild Things' is pure pulp fiction elevated by strong performances and a plot that delights in its own audacity, making it a fun, if scandalous, watch.

8. Damage (1992)
Damage is a dark, intense exploration of forbidden passion and its destructive consequences. Jeremy Irons delivers a captivating performance as Stephen Fleming, a respected politician who embarks on a dangerous affair with his son's fiancée. Juliette Binoche is equally compelling as Anna Barton, the enigmatic woman who ignites a consuming obsession. The film delves deep into the psychological toll of such a transgression, portraying a love that is both irresistible and utterly ruinous.\n\nDirected by Louis Malle, the film is visually stunning, creating an atmosphere of suffocating intimacy and impending doom. It's a slow-burn drama that relies heavily on the nuanced performances of its lead actors and the unspoken tensions between them. The movie doesn't shy away from the raw, often uncomfortable, aspects of illicit desire. \n\nOne poignant detail: the film's original title in French was 'Fatale,' which perfectly encapsulates the deadly allure of the central relationship. 'Damage' is a powerful, albeit unsettling, reminder of how quickly lives can unravel when passion overrides reason.

7. Cruel Intentions (1999)
Cruel Intentions is a deliciously wicked teen drama that reinterprets 'Les Liaisons Dangereuses' for the late 90s, injecting it with a fresh, edgy sensibility. Sarah Michelle Gellar and Ryan Phillippe are perfectly cast as the manipulative step-siblings Kathryn Merteuil and Sebastian Valmont, who engage in a cruel game of seduction and betrayal. Reese Witherspoon shines as the innocent target, Annette Hargrove, adding a genuine emotional core to the film's cynical facade. The film's sharp dialogue and scandalous plot twists made it an instant cult classic.\n\nDirector Roger Kumble expertly captures the privileged, self-absorbed world of New York's elite, creating an atmosphere of dark glamour and moral decay. The film doesn't shy away from exploring themes of power, desire, and the corrupting influence of boredom. It's a stylish, unapologetic look at the darker side of adolescent ambition. \n\nDid you know that the film's iconic soundtrack, featuring hits like 'Bitter Sweet Symphony' and 'Every You Every Me,' became almost as popular as the movie itself, perfectly encapsulating the mood of the era? 'Cruel Intentions' remains a guilty pleasure for many, a testament to its enduring appeal and its clever take on a classic tale.

6. Match Point (2005)
Match Point is a sharp, sophisticated thriller that marked a significant return to form for Woody Allen, trading his usual New York setting for the elegant, often ruthless, world of London's elite. Jonathan Rhys Meyers delivers a compelling performance as Chris Wilton, an ambitious tennis pro who becomes entangled in a dangerous affair, while Scarlett Johansson sizzles as the alluring Nola Rice. The film masterfully explores themes of luck, fate, and moral ambiguity, proving that sometimes, the biggest gamble isn't in love, but in getting away with it.\n\nAllen's direction here is precise and unsparing, building tension with a slow, deliberate pace that keeps you on the edge of your seat. The film's narrative is tightly woven, with consequences that feel both inevitable and chillingly random. It's a departure from his comedic roots, showcasing his ability to craft a truly gripping drama. \n\nA fascinating tidbit: Allen chose to use operatic music throughout the film, which perfectly complements the grand, tragic scope of the story, adding a layer of dramatic irony to Chris's increasingly desperate situation. 'Match Point' is a reminder that sometimes, the most dangerous game is played off the court.

5. Eyes Wide Shut (1999)
Stanley Kubrick's final masterpiece, Eyes Wide Shut, is a mesmerizing and unsettling journey into the hidden desires and anxieties lurking beneath the surface of a seemingly perfect marriage. Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman, at the height of their real-life partnership, deliver incredibly vulnerable and complex performances as Dr. Bill Harford and Alice Harford. Their on-screen chemistry, combined with the film's dreamlike atmosphere, makes for a truly immersive experience.\n\nKubrick meticulously crafted every frame, creating a world that feels both familiar and deeply surreal. The film explores themes of infidelity, jealousy, and the secret lives people lead, pushing the boundaries of what a mainstream Hollywood film could depict. Its slow-burn intensity and enigmatic narrative leave a lasting impression, inviting multiple viewings and interpretations. \n\nOne fascinating aspect is Kubrick's legendary attention to detail; he famously shot the film over 400 days, making it into the Guinness World Records for the longest continuous film shoot. This dedication is evident in every meticulously composed shot and the film's enduring, haunting quality. 'Eyes Wide Shut' is less a traditional thriller and more a psychological odyssey, a profound meditation on the complexities of human relationships.

4. Basic Instinct (1992)
Basic Instinct exploded onto screens in 1992, instantly becoming a benchmark for the neo-noir thriller. Sharon Stone's iconic performance as Catherine Tramell is nothing short of legendary—she's enigmatic, dangerous, and utterly captivating, a femme fatale for a new era. Michael Douglas, as detective Nick Curran, is perfectly cast as the man drawn into her perilous web. The chemistry between them is palpable, fueling the film's intense cat-and-mouse game.\n\nDirected by Paul Verhoeven, the movie is renowned for its stylish, often controversial, depiction of sexuality and violence, pushing boundaries and sparking endless discussion. The screenplay, by Joe Eszterhas, is full of twists and turns, keeping audiences guessing until the very end. Beyond the controversies, it's a masterclass in building suspense and creating an atmosphere of seductive danger. \n\nDid you know that the famous interrogation scene, which became one of the most talked-about moments in cinema history, was meticulously choreographed and rehearsed to achieve its shocking impact? The film's influence on subsequent thrillers is undeniable, cementing its place as a quintessential 90s classic.

3. Unfaithful (2002)
Unfaithful is a simmering, intense exploration of desire, betrayal, and the devastating ripple effects of a clandestine affair. Diane Lane delivers an absolutely mesmerizing, Oscar-nominated performance as Connie Sumner, a suburban wife who finds herself drawn into a passionate, dangerous liaison. Her portrayal is nuanced and raw, capturing the thrill, guilt, and eventual terror of her choices. Richard Gere, as her unsuspecting husband Edward, perfectly conveys the slow burn of suspicion and heartbreak, while Olivier Martinez exudes a captivating allure as the mysterious lover.\n\nAdrian Lyne, the director behind other iconic thrillers, once again proves his mastery of erotic tension and psychological drama. He creates an atmosphere thick with unspoken desires and mounting dread, making every stolen glance and secret meeting feel incredibly high-stakes. The film doesn't just show an affair; it delves into the emotional landscape of everyone involved, revealing the profound impact of infidelity on a seemingly perfect life. \n\nOne fascinating detail: the film is a remake of the 1969 French film 'La Femme Infidèle' by Claude Chabrol, but Lyne's version injects its own distinct intensity and a more modern sensibility, making it a truly compelling watch.

2. Fatal Attraction (1987)
Fatal Attraction isn't just a thriller; it's a masterclass in psychological suspense that redefined the genre. Michael Douglas and Glenn Close deliver powerhouse performances that are nothing short of electrifying. Close, as Alex Forrest, creates a character so chillingly obsessive that she became an instant cinematic icon, a testament to her incredible range. Douglas, as Dan Gallagher, perfectly embodies the man whose life unravels after a reckless decision.\n\nDirected by Adrian Lyne, who clearly has a knack for exploring the darker side of human relationships, the film meticulously ratchets up the tension, turning a seemingly innocent affair into a terrifying nightmare. The movie sparked widespread discussions about infidelity and its devastating consequences, becoming a cultural phenomenon in the late 80s. \n\nDid you know that the film originally had a different ending, which was changed after test audiences reacted strongly? The revised ending, now iconic, solidified its place in thriller history. The film's influence can still be seen in countless thrillers today, making it a must-watch for anyone interested in the genre.

1. Indecent Proposal (1993)
Indecent Proposal asks one of cinema's most provocative questions: what would you do for a million dollars? This 1993 drama, starring Robert Redford, Demi Moore, and Woody Harrelson, dives deep into the moral quagmire of a seemingly simple offer. Redford, as the enigmatic billionaire John Gage, exudes a captivating charm that makes his proposition both alluring and terrifying. Demi Moore delivers a powerful performance as Diana, the wife grappling with an impossible choice, while Woody Harrelson brings a raw vulnerability to David, the husband whose world is turned upside down. \n\nThe film became a cultural touchstone, sparking countless debates about love, trust, and the price of integrity. Director Adrian Lyne, known for his sleek, often controversial thrillers, masterfully builds tension and explores the psychological toll of such a decision. The cinematography is lush, highlighting the glamorous world Gage inhabits against the more grounded reality of the couple. \n\nDid you know that the film's iconic line, 'I offered you a million dollars for one night with your wife. What if I offered you a billion?' was improvised by Robert Redford? It truly added another layer of intrigue to an already fascinating premise. This movie isn't just a story; it's a thought experiment brought to life, leaving audiences pondering long after the credits roll.
